Tuesday, March 19, 2013

2013 Real Property Assessments

We have all received our 2013 real property assessments. And now we have to understand how the numbers were generated.  Like you, I could have been better prepared for the changes and thus, minimized my surprise. But unlike you, it is nominally my "job" to help keep you informed.  I am very sorry. 

To catch up, let's start with the contracted assessor himself, James Canary.  Mr. Canary responded quickly to yesterday's request for explanation:

To: Mayor Stephanie Scott;  Assembly Members
First of all thank you for the opportunity to be the Haines Borough Assessor and to allow me time to explain my methodology for assessed values for the Haines Borough.

As you are probably aware Alaska Assessment Services was asked to come in and help the Haines Borough with assessments for the tax year 2013. This was after an audit by the State Assessor was conducted.  My job was to help establish equity within the Borough and to bring assessments up to their full and true value as of January 1, 2013 based on Alaska State Statute, Title 29, Section 49.110, Full & True Value.

Background: Having knowledge of the Haines area as a real estate appraiser for over 17 years and as an Assessor for Juneau, Petersburg and Pelican along with working within the assessment system in Ketchikan, Craig, Petersburg and Juneau since 1984, I’m pretty familiar with the State of Alaska, Title 29, Section 49 and the assessment process.  Please understand, none of my confidential private Real Estate Appraisal information was used within the valuation process for the Haines Borough 2013 Assessment process.

Research:  After taking the job as the Haines Assessor in January 2013, my first course of action was to see what sales information the Haines Borough had collected.  I was pleasantly surprised to find some good sales data has been collected over the past number of years. I started out analyzing the last 3 years of sales data collected.  Of the sales data collected there were 236 Deed Title Changes with 126 Confirmed sales prices obtained (53% collection rate).   

Analysis: My second course of action was to analyze each and every confirmed sale and breakdown the difference between land and building for each sale. In some cases a site visit and questions to the buyer were needed to gather additional information.  I’d like to extend my appreciation to all that were willing to give me additional information, it really did help.  As most citizens in Haines are aware this job was very difficult as there are many different market areas in Haines and each was weighted on its own merit based on the sales obtained.  My analysis extracted raw land values by  location, density, upland vs. waterfront adjustments, view adjustments, topography adjustments, site development and other adjustments where noted.

Findings from the Sales Analysis:   What became evident from researching vacant (unimproved) sales and then improved sales (Buildings & Land), the difference was minimal with additional value given to improved sites for the driveway, site pad, water, sewer, electricity and telephone.  For developed properties with all of the above an adjustment of $20,000 was extracted from the sales on average.  While $20,000 is probably low for actual cost to develop a site an average was run for each and every parcel at this time minus some of these features resulted in a lower site development adjustment (Example: no roadway access, no power, etc).  This adjustment was on top of the raw land value given to each and every parcel within a specific location.  View adjustments were made at $10,000 for filtered views and $20,000 for good views this again was an average and run consistently throughout the Haines Borough.  Sites were run at a specific unimproved land value and then adjusted for density, size, view, topography, other adjustments along with the site development adjustment. I also researched the cost approach for buildings for each and every sale and found that some clean up still is required before implementing the cost approach across the board for the Haines area. Overall no change was made to the building cost as the prior costs were close to the new updated cost and local multiplier derived.

Applying Assessed Values for each parcel:  After the market analysis was concluded, I set up an excel spreadsheet and went through each and every market area based on the sales obtained, made the adjustments appropriate to the specific location, then went back and double and triple checked the numbers verses the sales. From the final draft an audit with the help of Dean Olsen was done and corrections were made as needed.

In Conclusion:  After the research, analysis and implementation of the 2013 Assessed values for the Haines Borough were completed the final verdict was that the Haines Borough Assessed Values had gone from a 85% sales ratio (Assessed  Value/Sales Price) in 2012 to a 98% sales ratio in 2013 with a total Assessed value increase of 18% overall.  I understand as a tax payer this increase is hard to swallow, but my job as the Assessor is to assess each and every property at full and true value as of January 1, 2013.

Let me field a couple of questions received so far:
1)     What if I feel my property is not assessed enough?   Answer you can also appeal to have your value raised.
2)     What if I feel I could not sell my property for what it is assessed at?  Answer is to appeal your assessment and allow the Assessor or staff to do a full inspection of the property.  If there is a reason to change it we will.
3)     What if my neighbors are assessed with different value methods?  Answer:  this can happen, but mostly in the downtown area where different zonings are taken into account or the neighboring properties are much larger than the parcel in question (Density: low, medium, high).  Let me clarify further:  Some areas of the downtown sold at different rates because of zoning, actual use or lot size.  Example a raw commercial lot in the downtown area sold for $3.00/SF and a residential house on a commercial zoned lot sold for $1.03/SF (side by side). The residential home sale on a commercial lot sold similar to a residential zoned home up the street.  In appraisal methodology a residential property in a commercial zoned area has an external loss either in the land or improvements.  I determined the land value should suffer the loss, each lot in a commercial zoned area in the downtown area is run at least $3/SF up to $10/SF.  A residential property in a commercial zoned area is run at $3.00/SF with a market adjustment (external loss) which brings the final land value to $1.03/SF before the other adjustments are applied (location, density, waterfront or upland, view, topography, other, and site development).  If on the other hand a lot is over let’s say half an acre and based on sales indicated a per acre basis should be applied then it was (residential zoning and residential lot).  (Half an acre is only an example, the valuation is based on the sales within the area in question)
4)      I live out the road and my lot is valued higher per acre than my neighbor?  Answer:  Out the road everybody within the area is run at the same per acre basis, but lots are adjusted based on size.  Based on the market sales size adjustments were required.  Example:  a 5 acre lot should sell for more per acre as compared to the neighboring lot of 50 acres.
5)     My lot is an upland lot, was it run the same as the waterfront lot below?   Answer: No, ocean waterfront, lakefront and riverfront properties were run at a different valuation, based on their sales for the area or a similar area.
6)     While I can’t disagree with the current market assessed value, I don’t like the fact I’m going to have to pay more taxes.  Answer: The Assessor is charged with full and true value determination as of the 1st of each year.  Taxes are assessed by the millage rate which is adopted by the Haines Borough.  This can go up or down depending on the budget set by the assembly.
7)     How can you justify increasing my assessment by more than 20% in one year?  Answer:  Your assessment was based on prior sales data for your area.  Now if you are having problems with your house or lot (rot, settlement, ants, erosion, etc.), appeal your assessment, the Assessor may not know about these issues.  An appeal gives the property owner the chance for the Assessor to take another look at the property.  That doesn’t mean that the Assessor will change the value.  If not satisfied the appellant can go to the board of equalization for a final hearing. 

I hope this sheds some light to the current 2013 Assessed Values for the Haines Borough.  If you have any further questions please ask.

Cordially;
James W. Canary, Assessor
I have some more questions that I have posed to the state assessor, Steve Van Sant today.  Please check back and I will post his responses as soon as I receive them.  Meanwhile, KHNS News Director Margaret Friedenauer also engaged Mr. Van Sant.  This is his response, received today,  to her inquiries:
There have been no changes in the state assessment laws in years with the exception of various exemptions that have been added.

Based upon our experience with the Haines Borough and the increases that residents have seen this year, the primary reason behind the increases is most likely the assessor attempting to catch up to the market.

State law requires municipalities to assess property at 100% of market value.  This has been the assessment standard for many years and it has not changed.  In our latest audit of the Haines assessments we noted that assessments appeared to be inequitable and many needed to be updated with current values as that did not appear to have been done in many years.  The 18 page report lists several areas that needed to be addressed and the borough is attempting to make needed corrections.

The Borough hired Mr. James Canary to get its values completed and assessment notices mailed out this year and Mr. Canary attempted to get most of the land values in equity and up to market value. He informed my office that he rebuilt the valuation models and tried to get most, if not all, properties valued in this fashion helping to assure more equity in the process.

Anytime a city or borough goes through a re-evaluation process values will usually increase and hopefully produce a more uniform assessment roll.

But the answer to your direct question is that the standard for assessments, market value, has not changed.
I note Mr. Van Sant's reference to an "18 page report."  I know I have seen that report but I need to see it again.  It may help give some context to our situation.  I will ask the Clerk to post it under key documents on the Borough website.  

Monday, March 4, 2013

Day Boat ACF Comment Period Extended by State

Deputy Commissioner Yost reports that time has been extended for comment on the Design Concept Report for the Day Boat Alaska Class Ferry (Day Boat ACF).  For details, see the email that I received today:
Hello Mayor Scott,

We have just posted a link on the AMHS website, under News & Updates/Alaska Class Ferry/Submit a Comment.

The link is:
http://www.dot.state.ak.us/amhs/alaska_class/submit_comment.shtml

We will also post a link on the DOT&PF homepage to direct folks to the ACF comment link.  The comment page explains that any comments addressing potential factual errors (e.g. route lengths, speed time calculations) should be submitted by March 15, 2013 (we have added a week to the March 8 date due to the delay in getting the comment link working).  The page also explains that while comments are welcome throughout the project’s development, general comments or questions on the concepts in the DCR should be submitted by March 29, 2013 in order to be used in development of the Design Study Report (DSR).  This will give the public ample opportunity to comment on the DCR before we move forward.  The consultant design team will evaluate the DCR and begin some of the analysis required to address issues already identified, but the DSR will be delayed until the latter part of April.
I appreciate the extension and will certainly say so tomorrow during testimony to the Joint House and Senate Transportation Committee public hearings on the Design Concept Report.  Please join us at the Haines Borough Public Library, 1:30, where we will watch the proceedings and testify in turn. It will be helpful to hear from others across the region if not the state.

There is a feeling called "deja vu" - when you sense that you have done this before.  I feel like we are repeating the experience the DOT had with the first Alaska Class Ferry design.  They went to the public and after 4 years of process, the design "morphed" into a vessel suitable for the route and suitable for the passengers on the route.  DOT has determined that the morphed vessel was a mistake; maybe so, but I worry about the alternative: clam-shell bow doors, open aft deck, fewer seats than passengers, no direct route from Skagway to Juneau, vending machines, an assumption that the vessels run "half empty" in the winter, no unaccompanied vehicles, and nothing if a $20 million terminal is not built... . I see lost revenue, even danger, and a plan that may be penny wise and pound foolish.  I see vessels designed to serve a system laced with yet unbuilt roads; and vessels that seem more suited to Puget Sound than to the upper Lynn Canal.  The original ACF was designed to serve the whole system, Skagway to Prince Rupert. Let's get back to it.


Saturday, March 2, 2013

What is the Public's Role in the Development of the Day Boat ACF?

We have been presented with a concept for a new AMHS vessel.  It is being called the "Day Boat Alaska Class Ferry" to distinguish it from the Alaska Class Ferry design that was withdrawn by Governor Parnell this past December.

By some accounts, the first group of Alaska Class Ferry planners engaged in a 4-6 year public review process.  And that, according to DOT/PF Commissioner Kemp, was the problem (as per testimony before the Joint Senate/House Transportation Committees, January 17, 2013).  The Alaska Class Ferry morphed from the original mission.  Rough order of magnitude estimates for construction reportedly exceeded the $120 million budget.  Rather than increase the budget, the decision was made to go back to the drawing board, but not to go back to the public.

The new concept, prepared by Coastwise Corporation for the State, was published February 25.  We are invited to submit comments by March 8.  I had trouble even finding the document on the DOT/PF website but that problem was quickly corrected.  Jeremy Woodrow, Communications Officer, emailed the following information March 1:
The Design Concept Report for the Day Boat ACF is available online via the Alaska Class Ferry website: http://www.dot.state.ak.us/amhs/alaska_class/

The link to download the entire report is titled "Design Concept Report" and it is located under the side menu that is titled "Day Boat Alaska Class Ferry."

We are also working on posting a link on the ACF website to make it easier for folks to submit their comments throughout the various steps of the project. In the meantime, anyone who would like to submit a comment may do so directly to Deputy Commissioner Yost: reuben.yost@alaska.gov
I was curious about the nature of the public comment period and its brevity, so I asked DOT/PF  Commissioner Kemp for clarification. Yesterday, Deputy Commissioner Reuben Yost explained why the documents were not easily accessible as well as the the nature of this brief comment period in an email to me:
I apologize that we don’t have a link on the ACF portion of the AMHS website for people to submit comments.  It was our intention to have that available now but due to some staff absences it will not happen until Monday.  Please post our Communications Officer Jeremy Woodrow’s email address (Jeremy.Woodrow@alaska.gov), but if comments are sent to me they will also be circulated to the appropriate DOT&PF staff.  Comments can also be submitted to MTAB members, as they are they are an official conduit for comment to DOT&PF on marine transportation matters.

I would like to clarify that this is not a formal comment period, there is no deadline for comment to DOT&PF on this issue, and the Department will consider all comments received throughout the design process.  In my presentation to MTAB I explained that the DCR was out for review and if someone saw something in the report that they thought was a factual error, it would be good to get that comment to us by March 8 so we could pass it on to the design team (Elliott Bay Design Group) to address in preparation of the next document in the process, the Design Study Report.  Unfortunately at the joint House-Senate Transportation Committee I did not have a chance to explain this fully as we ran out of time.  Connie will let the committee staff know this by copy of this email.  Please convey this information about the process on your website when you post the contact information.  As soon as we get the contact link up on the AMHS website we will provide this same information and inform readers as to the comment process we will have for the Design Study Report.
The House and Senate Transportation Committees are meeting jointly at 1:30 Tuesday, March 5, for the sole purpose of taking public testimony on the Draft Concept Report (DCR).  Dana Owen, staff to Senator Dennis Egan, Chair of the Senate Transportation Committee,  explained in a March 1 email that in order to accommodate everyone in the time available, Senator Egan has asked Mr. Yost and Captain Falvey be present but to respond in writing after the meeting to issues raised or questions asked and Senator Egan's office will distribute the information.  In other words, the hearing will not be a Q&A with DOT/PF.  It will be a time for the public to put their thoughts and concerns before the legislators and DOT/PF.

We do not yet have a Legislative Information Office in Haines so we are considered "off net."  The off net call in number is 855-463-5009.  The meeting should also be broadcast live on http://akl.tv. (We have found this linkage to be a little "iffy," still, I'd give it a try.  It is useful to see faces.)

One thought that I have had is to ask Coastwise Corporation (author of the report) and DOT to travel to Haines and Skagway and present the report directly to us.  We are hugely familiar with the landscape over which the vessel being planned must travel.  I believe this is a case when local knowledge applied to a plan can provide a benefit relatively inexpensively in the long run.  The public is not as expensive as the marine architect or naval engineer who may be called upon to correct a design if it is based on misperceptions of the landscape.  Frankly, I have been impressed by the recent public presentations by DOT planners and engineers relative to the plans to straighten the Haines Highway.  It is a fact that the planners have traveled on the highway they are planning to correct - repeatedly.  When a resident explains a concern with a particular point on the route, the planners seemed to recognize it immediately.  For sure, they knew the highway better than I did, though probably not better than those of us who travel it daily.  Their respect and curiosity for local input was obvious and reassuring.  It would be nice to know that Coastwise Corporation has been up and down the Inside Passage in all kinds of weather too, like we have.  If not, they should probably consult seriously with those who have.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Day Boat ACF - Read, Think, Comment

The Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities (DOT/PF) released the "Draft Design Concept Report (DCR) for the Day Boat ACF" February 25.  I found it a little tricky to locate the report on the DOT/PF website, so once downloaded, Borough staff posted the documents on the Borough website.  Click here for easy access.

The main report is 26-pages.  I've read it once through but it deserves to be read by people with background in ferries, terminals, and seas.  As with many topics, the more one knows about the ferry business, boats, currents, the more one can ask.  With just a glance, an AMHS employee quickly wondered about the plan to hold the ships to the docks with propulsion instead of mooring lines (see page 7). 

Page 8 talks about "no unaccompanied vessels," so I sent the document to Michael Ganey at AML wondering what kind of an impact this plan will have on AML's operation.

I wonder about designing for motion based on bow and stern seas only (page 16) but in other parts of the report, speculating about using these vessels to cross to the Katzehin (page 9).  And I especially wonder about the safety and reliability of the clam-shell bow doors. 

I'm not sure what to make about the repeated reference to designing a boat that enables drivers to be comfortable in their vehicles (pages 8 & 14).  I am also curious about the different passenger capacity numbers given (450 on page 3; 300 on page 19).  In both cases there are fewer seats provided than passengers allowed (300 and 200 respectively).  (Is this discrepancy built in because it is assumed that some of us will ride in our cars?)  On page 8 of the report, the authors state: "The Day Boat ACF needs to be designed to accommodate passengers on the Car Deck while underway."

A curious statement on page 17 leaves me wondering about the fate of the luggage cart.

Apparently, if this vessel is home ported in Haines, it will need to hook up to shore power (see page 16).  Do we have sufficient hydro power to accommodate that?   If not, what will be the effect on our rates when the diesels come on to provide the needed support?  Let's get this report into the hands of APT.

And yes, a partially open aft deck is proposed - as a cost saving measure.  The vehicles stowed there will be protected from spray by  "...bulwark walls high enough to safely shield the Car Deck from sea water including spray" (page. 18); additionally the bow will be specially designed to reduce spray. I just have to wonder if the concept designers (Coastwise Corporation) have seen the video from the wheel house of the Taku recorded this winter. White water repeatedly eclipsed the view, if only for seconds at a time. See more details of the proposed design for the aft deck in Appendix D.

I do believe I heard one of the presenters from DOT/PF at the MTAB meeting state that additional research would be done to further characterize the seas in the upper Lynn Canal as a result of comments from many riders.  I am thankful for that.

Our terminal will have to have a major modification to accommodate this vessel.  The cost of this is not addressed.

Cost:  On page 17, the authors state"...there is approximately $117 million remaining in the existing ACF funding."  The plan is to build two vessels for this amount.

The calendar for the project is aggressive:

This first report, called the Design Concept Report or DCR, was presented to MTAB yesterday and to the joint House/Senate Transportation Committees today.  I listened to MTAB; and I believe that Deputy Mayor Lapp may have been present.  Senator Egan's office solicited a comment yesterday but I hadn't fully read the report so I was unable to comment.  However, Mayor Selmer and I did request traffic data from the Haines Terminal, having heard DOT assert that few cars would need to ride outside in the proposed ferry because winter ferries often traveled lightly loaded.  (The Day Boat ACF provides for 53 vehicles, 30 under cover: the LeConte carries 44 and has traveled fully booked frequently this winter.)  No mechanism for public comment other than to send comments to Commissioner Reuben Yost, has been described.  However, the report does say that "Comments and questions in response to the DCR will be addressed during the next phase... ."  The next phase is the Design Study Report (DSR) and Concept Design.  This is to be completed March 31, 2013. The DSR will be presented to MTAB. 

I think it is far easier and perhaps even more effective to register concerns early in the process.  I recommend that the Assembly form a small committee and prepare a comment or a set of concerns to be approved at either our March 5 or 12 meeting and submitted to Commissioner Yost as soon as possible at reuben.yost@alaska.gov.

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Frankenfish

Senator Begich has appealed to Alaskans to speak out against the United States Federal Food and Drug Administration's decision of no significant environmental impact of the genetically altered Atlantic Salmon hybrid often called "Frankenfish."

According to an article in the Alaska Native News, Senator Begich said:
“Allowing questionable science to ultimately influence our food supply is a slippery slope that Alaskans don’t want to go down. I hope Alaskans take the time to submit their comment to the FDA and let them know we won’t tolerate science projects messing with our wild salmon supply.”
Closer to home, the City and Borough of Petersburg has appealed to municipalities to object to the FDA decision.  Eight Alaskan Representatives have introduced House Joint Resolution 5:
"Opposing the United States Food and Drug Administration's preliminary finding relating to genetically engineered salmon; urging further examination of genetically engineered salmon; opposing AquaBounty's petition to produce genetically engineered salmon; and proposing, if AquaBounty's petition is approved, that its product should be labeled as "genetically modified.""
The deadline for comments is February 25, 2013.  Because the Haines Borough Assembly does not meet until February 26, I took the liberty of forwarding Haines Borough Resolution 10-11-247, adopted November 30, 2010 to the sponsors of HJR5 and to the City and Borough of Petersburg. I will also make sure it is delivered to Senators Murkowski and Begich and Representative Don Young.

The Haines Borough Resolution 10-11-247 is titled:
"A Resolution of the Haines Borough Assembly opposing an application from AquaBounty Technologies, Inc. to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to approve and market genetically engineered Atlantic Salmon in the United States."
After citing the process that resulted in the genetically altered salmon,  and the lack of thorough scientific research and testing to ensure that consumption is safe; and reasoning that
"...this lack of safe consumption testing could weaken consumer confidence in all salmon products; " and Alaska's wild seafood industry "...could be severely impacted by the introduction of genetically engineered salmon,"
the Assembly resolved
"..that the Haines Borough opposes approval of genetically engineered salmon for release in the wild and for human consumption int he United States.... ; and "...calls upon the FDA to not approve the application from AquaBounty Technologies, Inc. to market and sell genetically engineered Atlantic salmon for human consumption in the United States."
More recently Senators Murkowski and Begich sponsored two bills opposing the FDA's stance:
Senator Murkowski joined Senator Mark Begich on two bills. One would make it illegal to sell, possess, transport or purchase GE salmon in the United States unless and until the NOAA approval process makes absolutely sure there is no harmful impact on  the environment – a claim that Murkowski is extremely dubious about, challenging the Food and Drug Administration on the floor of the Senate and through multiple legislative means. ...  The other bill defies the FDA’s stance against clearly labeling Frankenfish, requiring that GE salmon be clearly labeled and identified so that consumers can have full faith in natural salmon and know the difference on grocery shelves so they can be sure they are purchasing the real thing.
Also, Representative Don Young has introduced H.R. 584 which requires that all genetically engineered fish sold for consumption be labeled as such.

Many news outlets indicate that comments can be submitted electronically,  however, I've had no luck with the link.  So I mailed a copy of the Haines Borough Resolution to the address given for written comments:
-->
Division of Dockets Management (HFA-305)
Food and Drug Administration
5630 Fishers Lane, rm. 1061
Rockville, MD 20852

RE:  Docket No. FDA-2011-N-0899

Thursday, January 24, 2013

In Support of the Alaska Class Ferry

About a dozen of us huddled around a speaker phone in the library today waiting for our turn to testify before the joint meeting of the Senate and House Transportation Committees regarding the Govenor's plan to scuttle the Alaska Class Ferry.  We were able to watch the meeting on the big screen in the library but the audio was difficult.  However, we were a focused and attentive group. We got every word. We heard testimony objecting to the Governor's revision of the Alaska Class Ferry from Kake, Petersburg, Sitka, Yakutat, Ketchikan, Skagway, and Juneau. Testimony from Homer reminded the Legislators that this wasn't "just a southeast Alaska issue."  Representatives from the Juneau Chamber of Commerce and a speaker from Anchorage applauded the Governor's decision as cost-saving.  Locals Mike Denker, Debora Vogt, and Rob Goldberg spoke against the Governor's decision, as did I.  This is what I said:
-->
Although I am discouraged by the apparent disregard for the statutes that require DOT/PF to consult, if not collaborate with MTAB, I am confident that you as legislators have that particular concern well in hand, thus my testimony will focus on the outcome: safe, reliable , cost-effective marine transportation for Southeast Alaska in general and  Haines-Skagway-Juneau in particular.

1)   Commissioner Kemp, while admitting that the design for the smaller vessels is on his desk, has declined to say whether or not the design includes an open car deck. Please put an end to our speculation. The concerns we have about the knowledge base from which such a vessel could be proposed, erode our confidence in the operation of Alaska Marine Highway – confidence  that has been  hard won and finally established over the past six years - confidence that has been secured through the public process recently dismissed as a problem.  To date, prior to the scuttling of the Alaska Class Ferry, we have understood AMHS  to positively respond to our concerns, and this, I submit is the reason that confidence is up, ridership is up, revenue is up.  It is just bad business to erode this confidence.
2)   I have seen a video taken from the bridge of a ferry coming up Lynn Canal this winter.  Waves were breaking over the bow and smashing against the wheelhouse windows.  Certainly, an open-deck design will be much less expensive, but it will be much less reliable in the heavy seas of the Lynn Canal or even in the seas of Clarence Straits outside of Ketchikan.  Such a ferry will be a fair weather vessel much like the Chenga and the Fairweather, the "fast" ferries that cannot reliably sail in the Lynn Canal due to the high seas. This is Alaska. This is the Lynn Canal.  The state’s own consultant, Elliot Bay, in reporting on the expected patterns and frequency of wave height, says that their conclusions are based on inferred data. There are no buoys in the Lynn Canal to provide the  primary data needed. In this case, local knowledge has got to be considered.  But if that is not credible, perhaps the Committee might call in some AMHS captains to testify to the seas in the Lynn Canal.  Better yet, test the concept directly.  The state owns an open deck vessel.  The Lituya, designed by Coastwise Alaska, the group now consulting with DOT/PF.  She sails between Metlakatla and Ketchikan.  Trade her out with the LeConte and sail her in the Lynn Canal this February and March – not even in the worst weather.  See how it works.

3)   And while you are asking about costs, please make an effort to track precisely the expenditures related to this project.  Last Thursday Commissioner Kemp said that the Department was spending  $20-30,000/day.  How is this possible?  Commissioner Kemp said that they pulled the project as they were about to schedule tank tests in Norway.  Norway?  Why Norway?  The Interisland Ferry, built independently of the state, which sails the 4.5 hour route between KK and Hollis, was tank tested too.  Here in North America.  Perhaps DOT/PF could find out where and avoid the expense of a trip to Norway.  When accounting for the cost of a specially designed shuttle ferry, please include the cost of modifying terminals throughout SE to accommodate it.  After all,  isn’t redundancy an important element of the plan? Shouldn’t this ship enable the system to be scalable – bringing it to routes that need extra capacity for some reason; or replacing another vessel that is disabled for all the reasons that accompanying an aging fleet?  Ask for the costs of a vessel that cannot sail, for surely, if the vessel is not designed to handle the high seas of Lynn Canal, that will certainly be the case – there will be critical times of travel when it simply will not be able to go.  It will represent a stranded resource, as do the Fairweather and Chenga. Ships designed for speed, but not for speed in the Lynn Canal.

One more question of finance: would it be possible to see those estimates that have been provided by Elliot Bay and the Alaska Ship Yard that have caused all this trouble?  My own experience, brief and limited though it is, suggests that estimates based on a project that is only 35% designed are quite speculative.  If high, the design can be modified at that point; not scraped, modified.  Suggestions to modify would be welcome; the plan to scrap the Alaska Class Ferry is not. 


Recent Procedures

Recently the Assembly followed a procedure that may have been improper.  We met as a Committee of the Whole in public and then retired to executive session to discuss a personnel matter: the details of the manager's performance.

The matter we discussed is unquestionably one of the very few permitted to be discussed in executive session.  Even the outcome can be justified since it can be argued that Assembly directed itself in a labor negotiation and the outcome had been previously moved pending a specifically given direction. The problem is how we got there.

The convening of the Committee of the Whole was by motion adopted November 27, 2012. And although the meeting was subsequently posted as convened the discuss a matter that qualifies for executive session, the problem is that there wasn't a motion at that time specifically moving into Executive Session.  Our Charter (Article XVIII) Section 18.03 (B) states, "The general matter for consideration in executive session shall be expressed in the motion calling for the session."

If the session was improper, I am not exactly sure of the remedy.  But I have asked for clarification from our attorney.  I have also asked the Manager to schedule, as soon as possible, a briefing for the Assembly sitting as a Committee of the Whole, regarding the Open Meetings Act, and the specifications state and local pertaining to the singular exception to the Open Meetings Act: executive sessions.

Though I may be unclear about the procedures followed by the Assembly as a whole in order to convene this particular executive session, I am crystal clear about an error I made. Haines Borough Code clearly states that Executive Sessions are to be recorded.  The Clerk was not invited into the session, thus the responsibility to record defaulted to .... me.  And I failed to discharge that responsibility.  Here is a copy of the letter I sent to the Chilkat Valley News last night.  It was uncertain whether or not the editor would be able to include it in the upcoming paper.

I made an error at the Assembly Committee of the Whole meeting on January 22.  Though we met properly in executive session, I did not push the “go” button on the little recorder the Clerk thoughtfully laid out for me.  I should have. Borough code requires that “Audio recordings shall be made of all executive sessions.” These recordings can be heard only by the Mayor or a member who did not attend and was excused. Although there is no one eligible to hear the recording except me (all members except one attended; the absent member was not excused), I still feel awful that I overlooked the requirement to make a recording.  Clearly, I erred; and I apologize.
One of my predecessors advised me to read the Borough Code every night before I go to bed.  Sometimes I wish he had been more specific as to which sections when.  Please bear with us.  Don't hesitate to point out when we get things wrong.  And then stick with us as we work to get it right.  Thank you.