Thursday, January 24, 2013

Recent Procedures

Recently the Assembly followed a procedure that may have been improper.  We met as a Committee of the Whole in public and then retired to executive session to discuss a personnel matter: the details of the manager's performance.

The matter we discussed is unquestionably one of the very few permitted to be discussed in executive session.  Even the outcome can be justified since it can be argued that Assembly directed itself in a labor negotiation and the outcome had been previously moved pending a specifically given direction. The problem is how we got there.

The convening of the Committee of the Whole was by motion adopted November 27, 2012. And although the meeting was subsequently posted as convened the discuss a matter that qualifies for executive session, the problem is that there wasn't a motion at that time specifically moving into Executive Session.  Our Charter (Article XVIII) Section 18.03 (B) states, "The general matter for consideration in executive session shall be expressed in the motion calling for the session."

If the session was improper, I am not exactly sure of the remedy.  But I have asked for clarification from our attorney.  I have also asked the Manager to schedule, as soon as possible, a briefing for the Assembly sitting as a Committee of the Whole, regarding the Open Meetings Act, and the specifications state and local pertaining to the singular exception to the Open Meetings Act: executive sessions.

Though I may be unclear about the procedures followed by the Assembly as a whole in order to convene this particular executive session, I am crystal clear about an error I made. Haines Borough Code clearly states that Executive Sessions are to be recorded.  The Clerk was not invited into the session, thus the responsibility to record defaulted to .... me.  And I failed to discharge that responsibility.  Here is a copy of the letter I sent to the Chilkat Valley News last night.  It was uncertain whether or not the editor would be able to include it in the upcoming paper.

I made an error at the Assembly Committee of the Whole meeting on January 22.  Though we met properly in executive session, I did not push the “go” button on the little recorder the Clerk thoughtfully laid out for me.  I should have. Borough code requires that “Audio recordings shall be made of all executive sessions.” These recordings can be heard only by the Mayor or a member who did not attend and was excused. Although there is no one eligible to hear the recording except me (all members except one attended; the absent member was not excused), I still feel awful that I overlooked the requirement to make a recording.  Clearly, I erred; and I apologize.
One of my predecessors advised me to read the Borough Code every night before I go to bed.  Sometimes I wish he had been more specific as to which sections when.  Please bear with us.  Don't hesitate to point out when we get things wrong.  And then stick with us as we work to get it right.  Thank you.



Saturday, January 19, 2013

Contributions Sought to Help with Reward and Vet Bills in Arrow Shooting


Haines is shaken by the shooting by arrows of two dogs.  One piercing was fatal.  On Friday, the Haines Police Department posted a $500 reward "for information leading to the arrest and indictment of the person or persons involved in this crime.... The size of the reward may increase if donors provide additional funds."  The arrows are in the possession of the Police Department and are on their way to State Crime Lab for analysis.

This coming Tuesday night (January 22) Assembly Member Steve Vick will ask the Assembly to guarantee that the Police Department can access any additional resources it needs to solve this crime.  I fully support that, but I seriously doubt that I will be called upon to break any sort of tie! 

My heart goes out to the victims – both canine and human – but I am also concerned for the perpetrator.  This is a terrible deed to carry and as hard as it may be, my hope is that culprit will come forward, make a clean breast of it, and begin a process of restitution – both to the victims and the to community. When an event like this takes place, we all are heart broken. We all suffer.

The Haines Animal Rescue Kennel has created a PayPal account for members of the public to donate to the reward fund. 100% of all donations to this account will go to the Police Reward Fund. (You can also mail your support to the HBPD, Box 1209, Haines AK 99827.)

There has also been an account set up at the First National Bank of Alaska for those who would like to help the dogs owners pay their veterinary bills (estimated at $2,000). The account name is The Foxy Memorial Fund. 

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Joint House and Senate Transportation Committees Inquire into AK Ferry Change

Haines was able to watch the proceedings of the joint meeting of the House and Senate Transportation Committees today (Jan. 17) on the big screen at the Haines Borough Public Library.  The system was excellent.  Though we were not able to comment during this meeting, we were  able to send questions to Rep. Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins via email. The committees will meet jointly again on January 24 specifically for the purpose of taking public testimony.

I find it so ironic that this significant and serious conversation regarding the plan for improved ferry transportation is taking place on the 50th anniversary of the AMHS.  I am, nonetheless, holding stubbornly to a sense of celebration. However, I fight the feeling that AMHS is being swept aside by this turn of events.  That being said, I am very grateful to the Senators and Representatives on the Senate and House Transportation Committees who are giving so much attention to DOT/PF's proposals.  Committee members on the Senate side are Dennis Egan (Committee Chair), Fred Dyson (Vice-Chair), Hollis French, Click Bishop, and Anna Fairclough.  On the House side, Peggy Wilson (Chair), Doug Isaacson (Vice-Chair), Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, Lynn Gattis, Bob Lynn, Eric Feige, and Craig Johnson.

There are many lines of inquiry that I hope the legislators will pursue. For starters, here are two that "popped" for me:

1) Commissioner Kemp, while admitting that the design for the smaller vessels is on his desk, absolutely refused to say whether or not the design included an open car deck.  I have seen a video taken from the bridge of a ferry coming up Lynn Canal this winter.  Waves were breaking over the bow and smashing against the wheelhouse windows.  Certainly an open-deck design will be much less expensive, but it will be much less reliable in the heavy seas of the Lynn Canal or even in the seas of Clarence Straits outside of Ketchikan.  Such a ferry will be a fair weather vessel much like the Chenga and the Fairweather, the "fast" ferries that cannot reliably sail in the Lynn Canal due to the high seas. This is Alaska. This is the Lynn Canal. In this case, local knowledge has got to be considered.  But if that is not credible, perhaps the Committee might consider calling in some AMHS captains to testify to the seas in the Lynn Canal.

2) The route proposed for the two shuttle ferries is Haines-Skagway for one ferry (10 miles one way) and Haines-Juneau for the other.  There are quite a few logistical problems with this plan.  For one, just how many times a day will a ferry shuttle between Haines and Skagway?  What is the need? The traffic?  Seems to me that it will run empty if it runs more than once.   Also, if it is planning on revenue from passengers only, it will compete with private ferries that do just that. Second of all, Skagway travelers, bound for Juneau will have to disembark, cars, tractor trailors, and all, line up and reload on a different vessel.  Right now it takes an hour or less for the LeConte, coming from Skagway, to load Haines passengers and head for Juneau.  Skagway would like less time in the Haines port, not more; and especially not more complicated time - as would be the case if required to disembark and reload.

Dept. Commissioner Yost made an argument that having everyone from Skagway get off the ferry would save money devoted to security.  Please ask just exactly how much it costs to provide security for any ship when stopping over in a port as compared to a ship that off-loads all passengers in a port.  You can compare the security-related costs for the IFA (Ketchikan-Hollis) to the security-related costs for the LeConte on its present run, when it stops in Haines, bound for Juneau from Skagway. The IFA seems to have the same level of security as the LeConte even though the IFA completely off loads in Hollis, and then again in Ketchikan.  I know because I recently traveled on that ferry.

Monday, January 14, 2013

Questions for Alaska DOT/PF re AK Class Ferry

The Haines Borough Assembly meets specially Tuesday, January 15, to consider questions regarding the impact of the Governor's surprise December 4 announcement of an alternate to the Alaska Class Ferry for ferry service in the Upper Lynn Canal, throughout the system, and to the system itself.

On the advice of Representative Peggy Wilson (R-Wrangell) and Chair of House Transportation, the plan is to transmit the Assembly's questions to the House and Senate Transportation Committees.  In a teleconference with Rep. Wilson December 28, we were told that the House Transportation Committee would take up the discussion on January 22; however, Representative Wilson, as reported in Alaska Legislative Digest No.2/2013, has advanced the schedule, scheduling the discussion for January 17. At that time, the House and Senate Transportation Committees will meet jointly with DOT/PF to review Gov. Sean Parnell's announcement to replace the plan to construct a single, 350-foot Alaska Class Ferry with two smaller vessels.

The Haines Borough Assembly will look at this working draft of questions, considering additions, deletions, and modifications:

DRAFT

Purpose: Prepare Questions to transmit to the Joint meeting of the House and Senate Transportation Committees January 17 to assist in examination of Governor Parnell’s proposed replacement of the Alaska Class Ferry with two smaller vessels

Service Standard in Southeast Alaska: frequency, versatility, capacity, and backup

Demonstrate how the plan to use the smaller ferries meets the need for versatility. Small boats cannot operate any where except within state waters; where can they go?  Can they deal with Clarence Strait?  The smaller boats will not qualify for SOLAS so cannot run to Prince Rupert as could the Alaska Class Ferry.  The smaller, limited vessel, limits the options.  Haven’t the Fairweather and Chenga taught us that the more specialized the vessel, the more limited its deployment opportunities?

Please explain how the plan supports the Governor’s December 4 statement: “The smaller vessels will provide much-needed backup service should other vessels experience mechanical problems, and can add flexibility to the system when special community events require greater access,” by describing the routes and naming the communities these vessels can serve directly and in a back-up capacity.

How will the new plan address the needs for service in the Lynn Canal during periods of inclement weather, especially high seas? 

How do you know that the smaller ferries will be safe, reliable, and comfortable in the proposed routes?

The Role of the Marine Transportation Advisory Board (MTAB)

Wasn’t the purpose behind the MTAB process to get the design “right”?  Wasn’t the goal of the process to match the vessel to the need?  MTAB identified the actual need and the proper solutions were articulated in the form of a concept design.  Shouldn’t the focus be on funding the right tool for the job, as opposed to changing the tool?

Is the state willing to utilize the resources (experience and knowledge) of the MTAB  to inform the planning and design of the latest idea for an Alaska Class ferry?  

How does the State’s plan for the role of MTAB align with AS 19.65.180 (C) with respect to developing a strategic plan for the Alaska Marine Highway?

The Proposed Design for the Two Smaller Ferries to Replace the Alaska Class Ferry

How will the new plan address the needs for service in the Lynn Canal during periods of inclement weather, especially high seas? 

How do you know that the smaller ferries will be safe, reliable, and comfortable in the proposed routes?

There is a renewed focus on bow doors. Please explain why bow doors haven’t been used on vessels other than the Bartlett. While bow doors are said to offer great efficiency of roll-on/roll-off operation, the need to seal things properly to provide sufficient watertight integrity may result in significant construction and operation costs. There have been a couple of serious life-taking ferry accidents in the Baltic – all related to bow door failures.

Does not the proposed design, stern/bow roll-on/roll-off (RORO) require a specialized loading dock?  If so, how many communities have the appropriate facility and what is the cost of building the required facility?  Is this cost considered when estimating the savings from the change in plan?

A partially opened car deck configuration has been referenced in earlier discussions.  Will this be safe for the proposed routes?  If it is deemed unsafe, how will the change affect the cost of construction for the two smaller ferries?

Funds/Cost:  The purpose of the new plan is to control costs. How will it achieve this? “With declining oil production and declining state revenue, we have to be smarter with the people’s money while meeting Alaskans’ marine transportation needs.” (December 4, Press Release from Governor Parnell announcing new direction.)

We understand that the Alaska Class Ferry design was 35% complete, and that thus the cost estimates were in the same preliminary state.  Will you provide us with the same estimates provided you that led to your conclusion that the AK Class Ferry would run over budget?

To what level have the smaller ferries suggested as an alternative to the Alaska Class Ferry been designed?  To what level has the cost of construction been estimated?  Will you please provide us with the design and cost estimate documents?

It is probably true of ferries as with houses:  a small percentage of the cost is accounted for by construction (capital cost); the larger percentage is operation and maintenance. Please share with us the estimates of the operation and maintenance for one large Alaska Class Ferry, that that makes one round trip but that that can handle expected loads compared to the cost of operating 3 small shuttle ferries with crews several times a day.

Are the construction costs for the new terminals needed for the stern/bow roll on-roll off (RORO) vessel part of the cost savings?   

According to Commissioner Kemp’s December 20 report, the decision to build two smaller ferries instead of the Alaska Class Ferry is based in part on a prediction in a report of “a substantial increased cost that resulted in the highest annual AMHS subsidy of any alternative UAF analyzed” (page 2, Commissioner Kemp, 12/20/12).  The report is based on AMHS data from 2006.  Why do you have such confidence in a report based on 6-year-old data, knowing that utilization (both commercial and non-commercial) has increased in the interim?

How do you read the following sections of the UAF report that connect the highest increase in subsidy to a ferry-road combination as opposed to the replacement of the Malaspina by an Alaska Class Ferry?

Under Option 1B (Malaspina is replaced by an Alaska-Class shuttle ferry):
·      AMHS’ financial performance is only slightly worse than the status quo (Option 1A) (p.189)
·      Profitability index “is statistically identical to that of the Status Quo and is to be expected.” (p.191)

The Option 4 (Multiple Alaska-Class Ferry plus Juneau Access Highway) would (p.190):
·      Result in a greater operating subsidy than all options except for the “full” Service Expansion Option 3.
·      The revenues generated by the expanded Lynn Canal service fall well short of the level expected to accrue from the proposed capital expense.
·      In this option, revenue yield actually decreases while Marine Vessel Operating costs remain unchanged.
·      The solution – change the current labor contract:
·      Option 4 “appears the least ‘unprofitable’ of the six options.”  (p. 191)  --

The report concludes: “Options 1B and, 4 illustrate that ship replacement of one or more existing vessels with Alaska-Class ships will increase the subsidy requirement, particularly in Option 4 where the fleet size increases.”  (p. 193)

The per/mile ticket prices between Haines and Skagway are the highest in the system, sometimes 200% to 300% higher per/mile than on other legs of the Marine Highway.  How will the construction of lower cost ferries affect user costs, specifically in Lynn Canal?

Reorganization of the State Department of Transportation and Public Facilities

Why is it necessary  to eliminate the position of Deputy Commissioner of Marine Operations?  Where will the functions of the Deputy Commissioner be handled?   Help us understand the proposed reorganization and administrative structure. 

The Alaska Marine Highway is a statewide function similar to airports and road systems. It serves communities and commerce from Bellingham, Washington to  the Aleutians.  Where does it fit in the structure? 

Process Oriented Questions:

Why did the State wait so long, at such a cost (+/- $3 million), to weigh into a process that was producing something unwanted? Is there some element in the procurement regulations that needs to be addressed to avoid wasting funds in a similar manner in the future?

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Exploring New Directions for AMHS at the Local and Regional level

I am asking the Haines Borough Assembly to meet specially January 15 to prepare a set of questions regarding the new direction for the Alaska Class Ferry project proposed December 4 by Governor Parnell. We will transmit these questions to the Chair of the House Transportation Committee (Peggy Wilson, R-District 33, representating Ketchikan, Wrangell, and the northern part of Prince of Wales Island) for the Committee meeting on this topic scheduled for January 22. We can also distribute our questions to the Senate Transportation Committee, Chaired by Juneau Senator Dennis Egan; to the Marine Transportation Advisory Board (MTAB), and to Southeast Conference.

I met with Representative Wilson, Robert Venables (Chair - MTAB) and Haines resident Debra Vogt via teleconference on December 28.  Representative Wilson suggested that we can effectively work through her Committee. Our own Representative, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, also holds a seat on the Transportation Committee. 

I have presented a few "starter" questions to the Assembly in the January 8 Mayor's Report: 
How will the new plan address the needs for service in the Lynn Canal during periods of inclement weather, especially high seas?

Wasn’t the purpose behind the MTAB process to get the design “right”?  Wasn’t the goal of the process to match the vessel to the need?  MTAB identified the actual need and the proper solutions were articulated in the form of a concept design.  Shouldn’t the focus be on funding the right tool for the job, as opposed to changing the tool?

There is a renewed focus on bow doors. Please explain why bow doors haven’t been used on vessels other than the Bartlett. While bow doors are said to offer great efficiency of roll-on/roll-off operation, the need to seal things properly to provide sufficient water-tight integrity may result in significant construction and operation costs. There have been a couple of serious life-taking ferry accidents in the Baltic – all related to bow door failures.

Process Oriented Questions:

Why did the State wait so long, at such a cost (+/- $3 million), to weigh into a process that was producing something unwanted? Is there some element in the procurement regulations that needs to be addressed to avoid wasting funds in a similar manner in the future?
But I trust that there are additional thoughtfully formulated questions circulating in the community that will be helpful to the House Transportation Committee's  deliberations. 

The Southeast Conference Transportation Committee will have a second meeting on this topic, Monday, January 7, 10:30 AM.  The call in number is 1-888-550-5602, code 82494332.  I have a standing obligation during the week 8:30-11:30 AM so I will not be able to attend but I have notified Assembly members.  

I hope you have had a chance to read about Haines' role in the inception of the Alaska Marine Highway System on the system's webpage celebrating its 50th anniversary. Your voice, our voice, is an important to the future of the system now, as it was to its past. My intention is to work with you, the Governor, with DOT/PF, with Legislators to ensure that there is safe, reliable marine transportation to meet the needs of the people living in and traveling through the Upper Lynn Canal now and into the future.

Friday, December 28, 2012

Reply from DOT/PF re Alaska Class Ferry Changes

Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities (DOT/PF) Commissioner Kemp transmitted a paper today titled Alaska Class Ferry: Project Overview and Change in Direction.  Go to the Haines Borough website and click on Alaska Class Ferry Changes under "What's New" to download the document.

Read it and let's talk.

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Dear Governor Parnell....

Please tell us more about your alternative to the Alaska Class Ferry:
 
Governor Parnell, your decision, announced on December 4, to abandon the ongoing Alaska Class Ferry project in favor of smaller shuttle ferries raises many questions.  As Mayor of Haines, I have been inundated with comments, questions, and requests for information from Haines residents.  As to the questions and requests, I am as bereft of information as any of my constituents.  I cannot overemphasize the importance of this issue to my constituents.
            The Haines Borough Assembly will convene on Tuesday, January 8, 2013, and again on January 22nd.   Sometime during our January schedule, I expect that the assembly will wish to express a more formal opinion on this issue.  For that reason, I respectfully ask that you and your staff provide me with whatever of the following information that it is possible to assemble and transmit by early January, so that assembly members will be able to incorporate the information into their thinking.  I have tried to formulate questions that I think are key to our perception of the course change, but please do not hesitate to confine your response to my questions.  Please feel free to tell us what you believe we need to know in order to think clearly and carefully about your proposal.
            First, we are all very curious to know how the decision was made.  Your press release states that the decision was made “after it became apparent  … that building a 350-foot ferry, on budget, in Alaska, could not be accomplished.”  Where did these cost figures come from?  Who participated in this decision?
            Would, or should, the new plan be subject to legislative approval? 
            Why did you not follow established procedures for decisions about Alaska’s ferries?  The Marine Transportation Advisory Board was established in 2003 and adopted in statute in 2009.  It is a part of your Department of Transportation.  The MTAB was taken completely by surprise by this decision.  As far as I can discover, the Ketchikan shipyard was taken by surprise by this decision, as were Southeast Alaska legislators.  It looks to me as though your Deputy Commissioner for Marine Operations, Captain Michael Neussl was also surprised.  Many Haines residents feel that circumvention of the public process is one of the most important issues implicated by your decision.  How can I reassure them that participation in the public process is not in vain?
            If there is no design established yet for the two shuttle ferries your new plan contemplates, how can you make the statement:
            By setting a new course, Alaskans can build two smaller Alaska Class Ferries and stay on budget, and at the same time provide the same or better level of service Alaskans expect from our marine highways.
[Press release, Governor’s Office, December 4, 2012]
            What level of service do you believe is appropriate for Upper Lynn Canal?  By that I mean, how many cancellations or seasickness-inducing sailings are you planning for?  The Southeast Alaska Transportation Plan Shuttle Ferry Study, prepared in January of 2010, notes that
If the vessel is sized to the traffic demand, AMHS must ask of their customers whether a reduced reliability of service is acceptable, especially during the winter months.  If a vessel can make 99 out of 100 scheduled trips in the summer, but only 80 out of 100 trips in the winter, does that reach an acceptable level of service?  How should the ferry compare with other publically funded transportation such as the highways?  These are policy questions, not design questions.
            [Study, page 21]
            That study discusses wave conditions and wind speeds in various areas in Southeast.  While I am not familiar with the exact terminology used, I question whether the Elliot Bay group properly assessed conditions in Upper Lynn Canal.  The wave heights throughout the study appear to be underestimated. [1] The LeConte was cancelled twice this week due to 11-foot seas.  The past several weeks have seen sustained winds in the 55-knot range, with higher gusts.  While the LeConte (235’) was cancelled Wednesday and Friday, the Taku (352’) sailed Thursday, in essentially the same weather. 
            What connection, if any, does this change bear to the proposed Juneau Access Road?
            What is the conceptual design for the shuttle ferries?  Is it true that you are considering an at least partially open car deck?  [Did you see this recent picture of the LeConte in Upper Lynn Canal?]
 
            Your DOT Commissioner (Acting) Pat Kemp told me that his department is “going to assemble a paper that discusses the information and key points that led to the decision.”  [Email to me, Dec. 11, 2012]  Can you tell me when this study will be available?
            Finally, may I meet with you or your representative soon, in person or via teleconference, about our concerns?  Thank you. 


[1] It is also possible that sea conditions need to be reexamined in light of research that indicates that wind speeds and wave height will increase with global warming.  See http://www.researchgate.net/publication/50850792_Global_trends_in_wind_speed_and_wave_height